The figure we celebrate on February 14th is shrouded in mystery, with multiple saints named Valentine and conflicting stories about their lives and martyrdom. Here’s a look at the various legends surrounding this enigmatic figure.
The Multiple Valentines Problem
The Roman Catholic Church historically recognized at least three different Saint Valentines, all martyred on February 14th in different years:
Valentine of Rome was a priest martyred around 269 CE during the reign of Emperor Claudius II. Valentine of Terni was a bishop who met his end around the same period. A third Valentine was martyred in Africa alongside several companions, though little else is known about him.
The confusion deepens because the historical records are sparse and often contradictory. Some scholars believe Valentine of Rome and Valentine of Terni may actually be the same person, with different traditions preserving different aspects of one man’s story.
The Legend of Secret Marriages
The most popular legend tells of Valentine as a priest in Rome who defied Emperor Claudius II’s ban on marriages for young men. According to this story, Claudius believed that unmarried soldiers fought better than those with wives and families, so he outlawed marriage for military-age men. Valentine, believing this unjust, continued performing marriages in secret for young lovers.
When discovered, Valentine was imprisoned and sentenced to death. This legend connects Valentine directly to romantic love and explains why he became the patron saint of lovers, though historical evidence for Claudius’s marriage ban is lacking.
The Prison Romance
A related but distinct legend claims that while imprisoned, Valentine fell in love with his jailer’s daughter, possibly the jailer Asterius’s blind daughter. According to some versions, Valentine miraculously restored her sight through prayer. Before his execution on February 14th, he supposedly wrote her a letter signed “from your Valentine,” giving us the phrase still used today.
This touching story combines themes of miraculous healing, forbidden love, and tragic sacrifice, though it appears nowhere in the earliest accounts of Valentine’s life.
The Christian Matchmaker
Another tradition presents Valentine not as performing illegal weddings but as helping Christian couples marry and protecting persecuted Christians. In this version, he would give couples flowers from his garden, which led to flowers becoming associated with the holiday. He supposedly cut heart shapes from parchment to remind Christians of God’s love, creating an early connection between Valentine and heart symbols.
This legend emphasizes Valentine’s role as a protector of Christian love and marriage rather than as a rebel against secular authority.
The Martyr of Terni
The Valentine of Terni legend focuses on him as a bishop with healing powers. He reportedly cured the epileptic son of a Roman official, leading to the conversion of the official’s entire household. This miracle-working brought him to the attention of authorities, resulting in his interrogation, torture, and eventual beheading outside Rome.
Unlike the secret marriage story, this legend makes no connection to romance, instead emphasizing religious conversion and miraculous healing.
Medieval Embellishments
During the Middle Ages, particularly in Geoffrey Chaucer’s 14th-century poetry, Valentine became associated with courtly love and the mating season of birds. Chaucer’s poem “Parliament of Fowls” mentions Saint Valentine’s Day as when birds choose their mates, creating a new tradition largely disconnected from any historical Valentine.
Later medieval writers elaborated on the romantic aspects, adding details about love notes, tokens of affection, and Valentine as a patron of lovers. These additions reflected medieval courtly love traditions more than any historical reality about the saint.
The Historicity Question
Modern scholarship has cast doubt on many details of the Valentine legends. The earliest reliable mention of Saint Valentine comes from the Martyrologium Hieronymianum, a 5th-century martyrology, which simply lists a Valentine martyred on the Via Flaminia without biographical details.
The Passio Marii et Marthae, written centuries after Valentine’s supposed death, provides the first narrative accounts, but these texts blend legend, theology, and history in ways that make factual extraction difficult. Many colorful details appear to be pious inventions meant to inspire devotion rather than historical records.
The Church’s Modern Stance
In 1969, during reforms following Vatican II, the Catholic Church removed Saint Valentine from the General Roman Calendar, not because they denied his existence, but because so little could be verified about his life. He remains recognized as a saint, and local celebrations continue, but his feast day is no longer universally mandated.
This decision reflected the Church’s attempt to focus on saints with better historical documentation, though Valentine’s cultural significance ensured his continued popularity outside official liturgy.
Cultural Synthesis
What we celebrate today as Valentine’s Day represents a synthesis of these various legends, combined with pre-Christian fertility festivals like Lupercalia, medieval courtly love traditions, and modern commercial practices. The historical Valentine—or Valentines—has become less important than the cultural symbol he represents: sacrificial love, romantic devotion, and the courage to love despite obstacles.
Whether Valentine was one person or several, whether he performed secret marriages or simply ministered to persecuted Christians, his legends have served for centuries as a focal point for humanity’s enduring fascination with love, sacrifice, and devotion.
0 responses to “The Legends of Saint Valentine: A Historical Guide”